MARKET ANALYSIS

PokeInsider Index Report: All Four Card Indexes Slip, and the Cheaper the Card, the Harder It Fell

PokeInsider Index Report: All Four Card Indexes Slip, and the Cheaper the Card, the Harder It Fell

I am tracking a down week for all four PokeInsider card indexes: the Blue Chip fell least at -0.84% and the Micro Cap fell most at -1.92%. Here are the cards behind each move, why some moved and some didn’t, and what I am watching before the December 4 rebalance.

All four PokeInsider card indexes closed the week lower, and the size of each loss tracked the price of the cards. The PokeInsider Blue Chip held up best at -0.84%. The PokeInsider Micro Cap did worst at -1.92%. The Mid Cap (-1.49%) and Small Cap (-1.16%) fell in between, and the sealed indexes finished about flat.

The gap is wider since launch. All four card indexes started at 1,000 points on October 29. Three weeks later, the Blue Chip is the only one above that line (+2.67%), while the Micro Cap is down 5.81%. Money is staying in vintage high-end cards and leaving everyday modern cards. That fits what TCGplayer said this month about prices on the last five years or so of cards: they “continue to slide.”

How the indexes work: each one tracks 100 member cards. The level is price-weighted from raw (ungraded) sold prices and updated every morning. Because the index is price-weighted, the most expensive members move it most. One big sale on a $6,000 card counts for far more than the same percentage move on a $300 card.

Blue Chip: Lugia Crash and a Charizard Tug-of-War

The PokeInsider Blue Chip tracks the 100 most valuable Pokémon cards. It closed at 1,026.72, down 8.67 points (-0.84%) for the week. It traded between 1,018.30 and 1,039.46, a 21-point swing.

Lugia was the biggest drag. The Aquapolis Lugia fell 59.85% to $936.89 and took 7.65 points off the index. I found no news behind it. That raw reading is a TCGplayer Near Mint market price, and it sits well below every November eBay sale of an ungraded original I could find: roughly $1,600 to $3,500. Graded copies still look strong. According to PokeInsider’s Card Data (as of Nov 13), a PSA 9 sells for $28,539.90.

The 30th Celebration Classic Collection reprinted this card with the same 149/147 number and a 30th-anniversary stamp. According to PokeInsider’s Card Data, the reprint sells for $150.12 raw and logged 810 sales in the past 30 days. TCGplayer reported it slid from $150 to $130 this month. I can’t tell from the data whether the reprint is dragging down the original or whether this is one bad print in a thin market. For now there is no clear reason, and one reading this far below recent sales needs a second week before I trust it.

Charizard pulled both ways. The Gold Star Charizard jumped 26.29% to $6,125 and was the biggest gainer at +6.98 points. Skyridge Charizard (-18.67%) and 1st Edition Base Set Charizard (-12.38%) more than cancelled it out. Together, these three Charizards cost the index about 5 points. I found no news for any of them. Raw copies of these cards don’t sell often, so one sale can move the price by double digits.

Rayquaza has a likely tailwind. Mega Evolution—Delta Reign launched November 6 with Mega Rayquaza ex as its headline card. TCGplayer reported that demand for Mega Rayquaza ex 138/103 had already moved prices on other popular Rayquaza cards. According to PokeInsider’s Card Data, that Delta Reign card sells for $300 raw and $1,523.92 in PSA 10. The Gold Star Rayquaza also has a recent record behind it: per CGC, a CGC Pristine 10 copy sold for $1,020,000 in a Fanatics Collect auction in August. I found no specific sale behind this week’s +6.64%.

Shining Tyranitar 1st Edition (+30.61%) and the Legendary Collection reverse holo Psyduck (+51.28%) had no news I could find. Skyridge took a hit across the indexes: four Skyridge cards made the losers’ lists, and I found no news behind any of them.

Mid Cap: Broad Selling, Closed at the Low

The PokeInsider Mid Cap tracks the next 100 most valuable cards after the Blue Chip. It fell 14.90 points (-1.49%) to 988.15, which was also its low for the week (range 988.15 to 1,001.19). That is 1.19% below launch.

The headline losers don’t explain the whole week. The top four losers took 12.53 points and the top four gainers added 8.94, a net of about -3.6. The other 92 members cost the index about 11.3 points. That means most of the Mid Cap’s loss was spread across many cards rather than one blowup.

All four gainers are 2000-2004 cards (1st Edition Neo and Base, plus a Team Rocket Returns reverse holo). The worst loser was the POP Series 4 Sceptile, which nearly halved. I found no news on Sceptile or any of the other losers. Legendary Collection reverse holos landed on both sides this week: Psyduck +51% in the Blue Chip, Haunter -27% here. That kind of split usually means a few sales are setting the price.

Small Cap: The Top Movers Cancelled Out

The PokeInsider Small Cap tracks the 100 most-traded cards priced from $100 up to the Mid Cap. It fell 11.16 points (-1.16%) to 948.80, the bottom of its 948.80 to 959.87 range. It is now 5.12% below launch.

The top four gainers (+7.28 points) and top four losers (-6.86) almost cancelled each other out. So the Small Cap’s whole loss came from the rest of the list, which is the same broad weakness the Mid Cap showed.

Unlimited Base Set Charizard rose 13.60% to $320, while the 1st Edition copy in the Blue Chip fell 12.38%. I found no news for either. Gengar cards were mostly weak this week: Sabrina’s Gengar and both Phantom Forces Gengar EX cards fell, and so did the Skyridge Gengar in the Blue Chip. The Fossil Gengar in the Micro Cap went the other way, though, so I would not read this as a clear Gengar trend.

Micro Cap: One Mega Charizard Did Most of the Damage

The PokeInsider Micro Cap tracks the 100 most-traded cards under $100. It was the week’s worst index, down 18.39 points (-1.92%) to 941.90. Its range was 939.98 to 956.20, and it is 5.81% below launch.

The full-art M Charizard EX from Evolutions fell 36.42% to $67.50. That cost 7.10 points, close to 40% of the Micro Cap’s weekly loss. I found no reprint or news behind it. Recent eBay sales point higher: Near Mint copies sold for about $125 to $128 in early November, and a Moderately Played copy went for $93.45. Meanwhile its sister card, M Blastoise EX, rose 26.19%. Like the Lugia, this reading needs to hold for another week before I treat it as a new price.

According to PokeInsider’s Card Data (as of Nov 13), M Charizard EX sells for $154.50 in PSA 9 and $593.50 in PSA 10. If the $67.50 raw price holds, a PSA 10 is worth almost nine times a raw copy. PSA’s Value tier costs $39.99 and takes 90-100 business days, so that math only works for copies with a real shot at a 10.

Lillie’s Clefairy ex fits a pattern TCGplayer pointed out this month: Ascended Heroes cards are still drifting lower. The gainers mix older cards (Fossil Gengar, M Blastoise EX) with Mega Evolution cards like Mega Latias ex, and I found no specific news behind any of them.

Sealed: Nearly Flat, ETBs Lag

The sealed indexes work differently from the card indexes. Each one is an equal-weighted average of the daily price changes of the sealed products it tracks, and each started at 1,000 on August 1.

Premium Collections led the week (+0.69%) and still have the highest level. ETBs lagged again (-0.67%), and that index is the furthest below its starting level. Booster boxes are the only sealed index up over the month (+1.34%).

The newest products are still falling, but because the index is equal-weighted, older products that hold steady soften those drops. According to PokeInsider’s Card Data (TCGplayer market prices as of Nov 13), the Delta Reign Booster Box sells for $183.29 ($5.09 per pack, -2.9% in 7 days, -23.6% in 30 days). The Delta Reign Elite Trainer Box sells for $79.66 (-3.1% in 7 days, -25.6% in 30 days), and the Pokémon Center ETB sells for $132.80 (-14.1% in 7 days, -67.2% in 30 days). The 30th Celebration Ultra-Premium Collections are also lower: Day at $317.80 (-10.5% in 7 days) and Night at $355.63 (-5.6%).

What to Watch Next Week

  • More Delta Reign supply. The Delta Reign Build & Battle Box goes on sale November 20, per The Pokémon Company. Watch Delta Reign sealed prices and Mega Rayquaza ex, and whether the Rayquaza demand keeps lifting the Gold Star.
  • Japan, November 27. The Japanese MEGA expansion Aura Seeker (M7) releases. It is the base for the English Flowing Fists set.
  • More Classic Collection packs, December 4. The 30th Celebration Binder Collection and the 30th Celebration ex Tins ($21.99 MSRP) release. Watch the Classic Collection Lugia and Charizard reprints and the originals they copy.
  • Lugia and M Charizard EX. Both raw readings sit far below their recent eBay sales. If they bounce back, the Blue Chip and Micro Cap get points back. If they hold, these are new, lower prices.
  • Mid Cap and Small Cap at their lows. Both closed at the bottom of their weekly range, after broad selling rather than one bad card.
  • Rebalance. The next quarterly rebalance announces new members on December 4, effective December 21. Watch cards near the price lines. Fossil Gengar is now $110, above the Micro Cap’s $100 ceiling. Lillie’s Clefairy ex ($88.02) dropped further below that line, and Mega Gardevoir ex ($148.82) moved further above it.

What I Am Doing

The pattern is consistent so far: vintage high-end cards are holding, and the cheaper, more modern indexes keep falling. The realistic options are to buy the dips in the lower indexes, hold what you own until the December 4 rebalance and the 30th Celebration releases are priced in, or wait for the Lugia and M Charizard EX readings to settle before acting.

This report is market data, not investment advice.

What did you think?

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

What are you into? *

Most Popular

To Top