Prices for 3 Ponyta Pokémon cards from 2 sets: every Ponyta card worth about $25 or more, plus vintage holos in 1st Edition and Unlimited. The most valuable is Ponyta (Shiny) from Arceus at about $244.13 raw, and the top PSA 10 is Ponyta (Shiny) (Arceus) at $3,463.11. Raw prices are TCGplayer Near Mint (PriceCharting for vintage), graded prices are PriceCharting sales. Updated Oct 26, 2026.
Every Ponyta card price, most valuable first
Ponyta (Shiny)SH11 · Arceus$244.13PSA 10 $3,463.11
Ponyta (Toys R Us Promo)014/083 · Miscellaneous Cards & Products$133.48
Ponyta (UK Exclusive Promo)014/083 · Miscellaneous Cards & Products$91.75Card prices for every Pokémon · All card prices